The interaction between social determinants of schizophrenia and brain dopamine circuitry

Jean‐Paul Selten, Rik Schalbroeck, Jan Booij

It is well established that dopamine plays an important role in the pathogenesis of schizophrenia. A recent meta-analysis confirmed that striatal dopamine synthesis capacity and stress- or amphetamine-induced dopamine release are substantially increased in this disorder, and that both measures correlate with the severity of positive symptoms1. Meta-analytic evidence points to several social risk factors for schizophrenia (or proxies for such factors): urban upbringing, childhood trauma, low academic achievement, a personal or parental history of migration from a developing country to Europe, African-American ancestry, hearing impairment, and the presence of autism2. An important question, therefore, is whether exposure to these risk factors can influence dopamine function before the onset of the disorder. Dopamine function in the living human brain can be assessed using single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) or positron emission tomography (PET). We conducted a systematic review of SPECT and PET studies of the relationship between chronic social stressors and striatal dopamine functioning, and obtained fairly consistent evidence of an association between childhood trauma and increased striatal dopamine synthesis and release3. This finding suggests that the relationship between childhood trauma and schizophrenia may be mediated by dopamine dysregulation. In contrast, the results of six investigations of the relationship between educational attainment and dopamine D2/3 receptor availability were mainly negative (no association)3. A study of first- and second-generation immigrants (healthy volunteers, subjects at high risk of psychosis, and antipsychotic-naïve patients with schizophrenia) and non-immigrants (divided into the same three clinical groups) examined striatal dopamine release after exposure to a psychological stressor while in the scanner. The results showed an increased striatal dopamine release for immigrants in each clinical group4. The same researchers also examined striatal dopamine synthesis capacity in immigrants and non-immigrants, divided into healthy volunteers and subjects at high risk of psychosis. The synthesis capacity was higher in immigrants than in non-immigrants and this finding applied, again, to both clinical groups4. A study of non-psychotic young adults with severe hearing impairment revealed a greater amphetamine-induced striatal dopamine release, which constitutes evidence of a sensitized dopamine system. An investigation of non-psychotic individuals with autism found, instead, no increase in striatal dopamine synthesis capacity3. A PET study of healthy individuals in New York examined the relationship between genetic ancestry and striatal dopamine D2/3 receptor availability5. African and European ancestry differentially predicted this availability in the dorsal striatum (caudate nucleus and putamen). African ancestry predicted the availability negatively, while European ancestry predicted it positively. The results remained statistically significant after correction for age, sex, body mass index, level of education, smoking status, and estimated socio-economic status. The effects, of moderate size, were not driven by variation in dopaminergic candidate genes. The reduced dopamine D2/3 receptor availability in individuals of African ancestry probably means that more receptors are occupied by endogenous dopamine, reflecting a more active dopaminergic system. It is important to clarify whether this putatively greater dopaminergic activity in people of African ancestry is a direct genetic effect or a consequence of their social status. This is not a side issue, because social status (standing, rank, prestige) appears to be the most important single predictor of our health and lifespan, which remains strong after adjustment for behavioral habits such as diet, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, and exercise6. Social status and economic situation are correlated, but also different. This becomes clear if one considers the ups and downs of migrants from developing countries in Europe: migration improves their economic situation, but is often accompanied by a decline in their social status. Social status affects our health profoundly in that it determines to a large degree how autonomous we are and to what extent we participate socially. The suffering due to a subordinate position or outsider status damages health in ways that are as yet incompletely understood. Research into the relationship between social status and dopamine function is very interesting, but not easy. First, the phenomenon is complex, because humans belong to multiple hierarchies (e.g., appearance, intelligence, income, social and physical abilities). Second, the measurement of social status requires effort: in the absence of individual measures, one can use group membership as an approximation. This is the approach of the social defeat hypothesis of schizophrenia, which posits that low social status and repeated humiliation increase the risk of developing the disorder in the presence of a poor homeostatic control of dopamine neurons in the dorsal striatum2. The results of research in rodents provide strong encouragement to continue this work. The vast majority of this research has relied upon the chronic social defeat stress procedure7. This involves placing a male test mouse in the home cage of a larger, male breeder mouse, screened for a sufficient level of aggressive activity. is for after which the are for by a This is repeated for with a mouse each of three social and while a are The in the brain of are an increase in of dopamine neurons that from the to the nucleus and an effect in dopamine neurons from the to the in contrast, activity after the for our is the that social defeat to of the dopamine studies in rodents that social repeated exposure to and to The of can the function of neurons in the their to and the dopamine whether or are most is a function of their social In the physical of can a position In a higher is with stress and with a greater or availability of striatal dopamine D2/3 which may a level of striatal that these of dopamine are the than the of in the for human studies in this are the high due to the use of the to several of dopamine function in one and the high New such as are and may to this of In SPECT and PET studies provide evidence of increased synthesis of dopamine trauma, increased dopamine release trauma, hearing and D2/3 receptor availability in the This is to be for the pathogenesis of schizophrenia and research the relationship between social status and dopamine which can also be to health is Physical interaction permitted 5-10 min, mice separated 24 hours plexiglass barrier. every day 10 consecutive days, different dominant time. Two out defeated mice develop avoidance anhedonia-like symptoms, third resilient. main findings sensitive mice phasic firing mesolimbic project ventral tegmental area accumbens, opposite projecting ventral tegmental area prefrontal cortex. Resilient mice, display normal firing procedure. Important story possibility leads destabilization mesolimbic system via synaptic pruning. Indeed, have shown stressors, including dominant animals, activate microglia lead excessive synaptic pruning. loss synapses then disrupt pyramidal cortex, disinhibit projections meso-striatal regions destabilize meso-striatal system8. Among primates, low- high-ranking animals stressed organization. some species, demands frequent fighting make dominant stressful. cynomolgus macaques, however, rank associated less amount receptors, reflect lower synaptic dopamine. Well-designed experiments have shown aspects functioning consequence, rather cause, place hierarchy9. Major problems area refusal rates radiotracers, impossibility assess aspects session, costs. techniques neuromelanin-sensitive magnetic resonance imaging emerging, help expand field research. conclusion, preliminary (childhood migration), (childhood migration, impairment) diminished (African-American ancestry) striatum. likely relevant schizophrenia-related disorders. Further on function, relevant other mental conditions, needed.